Capitol Weekly Podcast

Gaming the system: Paul Mitchell on the impact of prediction markets and bad polls

Episode Summary

A poll from Median Strategies roiled the Los Angeles mayoral race earlier this month, showing Mayor Karen Bass with an 11 point lead over challenger Nithya Raman. The results were cited by several media outlets, and were touted by the Bass campaign before the poll was exposed as fake. When contacted, Median Strategies posted a statement that their polling had been "a short-term social experiment examining how purported polling information could enter and spread through the political information ecosystem without independent verification." Social experiment or not, the poll did impact the race - at least in the short term - and certainly impacted election prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket. Political data expert Paul Mitchell joined us to talk about how junk polls, paid influencers and strategic gaming of the election markets can distort perceptions about a campaign. Plus, who had the Worst Week in California Politics? 2:01 "That's the Pacific Ocean" 4:35 Capitol Weekly Internship 7:30 Death penalty 9:04 Paul Mitchell 10:23 Bogus polling 13:37 Picked up by media 17:02 "Everybody's a pundit" 20:48 Prediction markets 22:13 $7M bet on Spencer Pratt AFTER the election 23:56 Could prediction markets replace polling? 27:15 How is this legal? 30:05 Predictit 31:35 A note about gaming 34:01 Duane Dichiara debt 34:48 Scott Lay's election pool 35:33 Junk polls designed to generate coverage 38:28 "Traditionally, your campaign's internal polling is some of the highest quality polling" 41:03 What California race should people be watching more closely? 43:15 The split in the Democratic Party 47:14 #WWCA

Episode Notes

A poll from Median Strategies roiled the Los Angeles mayoral race earlier this month, showing Mayor Karen Bass with an 11 point lead over challenger Nithya Raman. The results were cited by several media outlets, and were touted by the Bass campaign before the poll was exposed as fake. When contacted, Median Strategies posted a statement that their polling had been "a short-term social experiment examining how purported polling information could enter and spread through the political information ecosystem without independent verification." 

Social experiment or not, the poll did impact the race - at least in the short term - and certainly impacted election prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket. Political data expert Paul Mitchell joined us to talk about how junk polls, paid influencers and strategic gaming of the election markets can distort perceptions about a campaign. Plus, who had the Worst Week in California Politics?

2:01 "That's the Pacific Ocean"

4:35 Capitol Weekly Internship

7:30 Death penalty

9:04 Paul Mitchell

10:23 Bogus polling

13:37 Picked up by media

17:02 "Everybody's a pundit"

20:48 Prediction markets

22:13 $7M bet on Spencer Pratt AFTER the election

23:56 Could prediction markets replace polling?

27:15 How is this legal?

30:05 Predictit

31:35 A note about gaming

34:01 Duane Dichiara debt

34:48 Scott Lay's election pool

35:33 Junk polls designed to generate coverage

38:28 "Traditionally, your campaign's internal polling is some of the highest quality polling"

41:03 What California race should people be watching more closely?

43:15 The split in the Democratic Party

47:14 #WWCA
Want to support the Capitol Weekly Podcast? Make your tax deductible donation

here: capitolweekly.net/donations/

Capitol Weekly Podcast theme is "Pickin' My Way" by Eddie Lang 

"#WorstWeekCA" Beat provided by freebeats.io